So you see, there was a spaceship. So it came and abducted something. The next poster says what they used to replace it and then the aliens come again, taking something else!
So:
There was a spaceship and it abducted toilet paper
Next poster:
Replacement was a sponge.
Then they abducted a monkey.
Replacement was a potato
Then they abducted a shoe
Replacement was a boot.
Then they abducted a slipper.
Replacement was a rubber duckie.
Then they abducted Cartman.
Replacement was Kenny...
Then they abducted Ike(south park)...
Replacement was Ike (nobody wants him)
Then they abducted Black Star...
Replacement was an astroswitch
Then they abducted Kit Kat
Replacement was pudding.
Then they abducted Luffy ...
Replacement was Ace
Then they abducted Akainu
Replacement was poop.
Then they abducted the next poster.
Replacement was Kamen Rider Joker-Limmy in Hyper Kiva Zeronos form
Then they abducted 01 and her alpaca
Replacement : not available
Then they abducted a reindeer ..
Replacement was Tony Tony Chopper
Then they abducted a goat
replacement was the brony bandage on my finger.
then the abducted ironman.
Replacement was another Kamen Rider
Then they abducted Momotaros
Replacement was Tengu.
Then they abducted 01.
The replacement is a loli.
Then they abducted Diamond Dave.
Replacement was Michael Jackson.
Then they abducted Will Smith....
The replacement was a prince who was rather fresh.
Then they abducted Perfume...
...the replacement was Dir en Grey.
Then they abducted Boy George...
The replacement was a chameleon.
Then they abducted David Bowie.
Replacement was Flea
Then they abducted the vodka
Replacement was this second page.
Then the abducted a weeaboo...
...the replacement was stink lines.
Then they abducted JonTron...
...the replacement was Andy Milonakis.
Then they abducted Bob Ross...
The replacement was John Oates.
Then they abducted Daryl Hall.
Replacement was a whopper malt ball.
Then they abducted a squirrel.
Replacement was the Hulk.
Then they abducted the Tessarect.
Replacement was a Pylon
Then they abducted a probe
Replacement was a victim.
Then the abducted a Kappa.
...the replacement was anouther kappa.
Then they abducted a rock star...
Replacement was Dave Grohl
Then they abducted Kratos
replacement was Marcus.
Then they abudcted Edward(twilight)...
Replacement was Dark Kiva
Then they abducted Decade (Kamen Rider)
Replacement was Red Ranger
Then they abducted Millenium Earl.
Replacement was Allen Walker.
Then they abducted the toilets ...
Replacement was a golden toilet.
Then they abducted Ron Swanson
Replacement was Joe Swanson.
Then they abducted Knuckles.
Replacement was Tails
Then they abducted Tyler from Fight Club
Replacement was Mike Tyson.
Then they abducted Kerrigan(StarCraft)
Replacement was a marshmallow.
Then they abducted PinkHairSasuke.
Replacement was SasukeHairPink
Then they abducted Butters
Replacement was Commander Chaos
Then they abducted Kenny
Replacement was Darth Chef.
Then they abducted Pinkie Pie.
Replacement was pewdiepie.
Then they abducted a fire hydrant.
Replacement was the #20 Fire astroswitch.
Then they abducted a donkey...
Replacement was a comedian.
Then they abducted an ogre...
Replacement was True Ogre
Then they abducted Bryan Fury
Replacement was Akihiko Sanada.
Then they abducted Rockman.
Replacement was Megaman
Then they abducted Akuma...
The replacement was Ganondorf.
Then they abducted a jar of pickles.
Replacement is the Mr. Pickles man.
Then they abducted Mr. Pickles man.
Then everyone cried and couldn't replace him due to his significance.
Then they abducted a pickle tree.
Replacement is a Banana tree.
Then they abducted sloths
Replacement was limDsage.
Then they abducted limDsage.
The replacement was a sloth.
Then they abducted baths.
Replacement is a hot spring.
Then they abducted Fourze
The replacement was a Fiveze.
Then they abducted the Sixze.
The replacement was Zack Ryder.
Then they abducted Ke$ha.
The replacement was eminem.
Then they abducted Cartman.
Replacement is The Coon
Then they kidnapped Swiftor
Replacement was Scizor.
Then they abducted the whole cast of Kamen Rider.
*They replaced it with the cast of Power Rangers*
*then they abducted the cast of Bram's Stroker's Dracula(1992)*
*Replacement is the cast of Twilight*
*Then they abducted the new Kamen Rider*
Then all the Kamen Rider fans rejoiced.
Then they abducted Comic-Con.
Replacement is MangaCon
Then they abducted Tesla
Replacement was a portal gun.
Then they abducted a duck.
Replacement is a swan.
Then they abducted Brock Samson...
...replacement was the biblical Samson.
Then they abducted Conan the barbarian...
Replacement is Coco.
Then they abducted Ash Williams...
replacement was Duke Nukem...
Then they abducted Brian Griffin....
Replacement is Snoopy
Then they abducted Ozzy
Replacement was Anime Expo
Then the abducted Kraken con
Replacement was Dragon Con.
Then they abducted a Grump.
Replacement is Grumpy
Then they abducted Ogre2
Replacement was OneyNG.
Then they abducted JonTron.
Replacement is Aris
Then they abdcuted ChrisG
Replacement was Christopher Walken.
Then they abducted toffee.
Replacement is coffee.
Then they abducted Soulfly
replacement was Slayer.
Then they abducted Scruffy...
(lol, There was a badass gangster dog that would walk the streets named Scruffy. I imagine that he fought the group gangster cats.)
...the replacement was a gangster cat.
Then they abducted Hawai'i...
Replacement is Puerto Rico
Then they abducted Kamina..
Replacement is Jersey Shore.
Then they abducted Hulk Hogan
Replacement is Jinpachi Mishima
Then they abducted the Venture bros.
Replacement was Johnny Quest.
Then they abducted the Hardy Boys(not the wrestlers).
Replacement is Shotaro Hidari and Philip
Then they abducted Salty Bets...
Replacement was Indiana Jones.
Then they abducted James Cameron.
Replacement is Stanley Kubrick
Then they abducted Akuma
...they replaced them with demons.
They they abducted angels...
They were replaced by Olympians.
Then they abducted Percy Jackson...
Replacement was Perry Johnson.
Then they abducted my bike.
Replacement is a Triumph bike
Then they abducted Handsome Jack
Replacement is Average Joe.
Then they abducted the Original Joe.
They replaced him with me.
Then they abducted my psychotic ex...
The replacement was your psychotic plus sign.
Then they abducted the burrito.
Replacement is a chimichanga
Then they abducted goats.
Replacement was sheep.
Then they abducted rats.
Replacement was a region on of plagued people.
Then they abducted tea.
The tea was replaced with coffee.
Then they abducted coffee...
Replacement was a German sparkle party.
Then they abducted all of the decaffeinated people.
Replacement was a bunch of mimes.
Then they abducted clowns.
Replacement was crowns.
Then they abducted shoulders.
Replacement are knees.
Then they abducted Uncle Sensei
Replacement was "Baddest Santa".
Then they abducted Björn Ove Ingemar
Replacement was Ice Cube.
Then they abducted a kirian.
...and replaced it with an Elementary OS.
Then they abducted ISIS...
Replacement is Achmed
Then they abducted Kotomine Kirei..
Its replacement was Haji
Then they abducted Relena Peacecraft...
Replacement was a taco truck.
Then they abducted Fall Out Boy.
Replacement was Citrus Girl.
Then they abducted books.
Replacements were codices.
Then they abducted doors.
Replacements were curtains.
Then they abducted Zangief.