Usually they want you to bring a credit card they can charge room damages/incidentals to. If you didn't prepay entirely, they'll charge the card upon check in. I've never had a hotel expect the same card. I often reserve with one card and present another at check in and have never had a problem.
I'd just call the desk and ask if you have to bring the same card you made the reservation with, or if another is acceptable. They don't really care what credit card it is, as long as they have a way to bill you in case you hurt anything.
I'd just call the desk and ask if you have to bring the same card you made the reservation with, or if another is acceptable. They don't really care what credit card it is, as long as they have a way to bill you in case you hurt anything.