<.< >.> <.< I'm not staff, but I can share personal experience from last year.
A) The rules are based on judgement, and everyone's judgement is different--and sometimes the same person will change their mind from year to year based on what they've seen happen.
B) My friend was last year's most popular Sephiroth. ^_^ (it's the wig, I tell you!) He had a 6 foot real sword and was made to tie it to his back as well as the regular zip-ties. It messed up his costume and made walking awkward, especially since the sword is longer than he is tall, but it was the only way they'd let him carry it around. He once drew it, out in front, to help make a video, but since got in mass tons of trouble because that violates California law.
C) I also saw ten-foot cardboard Inuyasha swords. :D Honestly, how can you secure that to a costume? It's huge! But they were still peace-bonded to remind the owners not to bop people on the head with them.
D) Last year I carried a wooden baseball bat... That's a weapon, my friends, 3-4 feet long. They peace-bonded it only after a lively debate among the staff and a LOT of questions about whether I could possibly, in any way at all, wear it as a costume piece instead of carrying it. I think the deciding factor was that I have a bad leg and mostly use it as a cane. XP Not sure if they'll let me do that two years in a row (which would suck, because I'd have to use the stupid crutches, but there you have it).
A) The rules are based on judgement, and everyone's judgement is different--and sometimes the same person will change their mind from year to year based on what they've seen happen.
B) My friend was last year's most popular Sephiroth. ^_^ (it's the wig, I tell you!) He had a 6 foot real sword and was made to tie it to his back as well as the regular zip-ties. It messed up his costume and made walking awkward, especially since the sword is longer than he is tall, but it was the only way they'd let him carry it around. He once drew it, out in front, to help make a video, but since got in mass tons of trouble because that violates California law.
C) I also saw ten-foot cardboard Inuyasha swords. :D Honestly, how can you secure that to a costume? It's huge! But they were still peace-bonded to remind the owners not to bop people on the head with them.
D) Last year I carried a wooden baseball bat... That's a weapon, my friends, 3-4 feet long. They peace-bonded it only after a lively debate among the staff and a LOT of questions about whether I could possibly, in any way at all, wear it as a costume piece instead of carrying it. I think the deciding factor was that I have a bad leg and mostly use it as a cane. XP Not sure if they'll let me do that two years in a row (which would suck, because I'd have to use the stupid crutches, but there you have it).