that's kind of what rock band is about. anyone can get a high score, but if they can rock out on stage and get the audience engaged, thats what a rock band is actually about. most rock band and guitar hero tournaments actually regard presentation higher than score. There was this one tournament where PristMLH (almost best GH player in world) 5 starred jordan and nearly got 100 %, but this other guy Freddy, was just doing stage dives and all this stuff and even though he missed a lot of notes, he won because he looked more presentable than just a guy standing there. So yeah, it might be a little bit of a popularity contest, but in all fairness, that's what bands are about.